What is the correct scenario if Broker Paul sells a house with various types of listings in effect?

In a scenario where Broker Paul sells a house with various types of listings in effect, John and Carole's entitlements to commissions can depend on the agreements they have in place with Broker Paul. If John and Carole are working under their own separate listings, typically under exclusive agreements, each might be entitled to the full commission for their own respective services.

This means that if both John and Carole were responsible for bringing in potential buyers or playing significant roles in the sale, they could both justifiably claim a full commission based on their individual contributions to the transaction. The nature of real estate listings often allows for this kind of commission structure, especially if they have exclusive rights to sell.

Therefore, it is entirely reasonable for both John and Carole to be entitled to a full commission if their respective agreements with Paul substantiate this claim, supporting the premise that each has fulfilled their obligations leading to the sale.